For readers who haven't noticed, I have already rolled content from my other blog into free scribbles. That blog was an attempt to talk about marketing, advertising, and the internet. As if here wasn't a hodgepodge already. With that said, I wanted to write about the stuff that really pays the bills. Three things happened recently that have got me thinking about originality and protecting those thoughts.
The first came from a blog post at Artificial Simplicity, a new blog written by a very smart man, Scott, that I had the privilege to work with, learn from, and run with (often simultaneously). His post on originality had me thinking instantaneously. But my response was stuck, second guessed, and ultimately silent (we'll get back to that).
The second thing was a question that came up today during a presentation about the findings from a social media experiment that Scott started before he departed on to his new position. I had the opportunity to stand in front of my colleagues and help them get a better understanding of social media. While another individual was discussing the photo-sharing site, Flickr, a question was raised about how a photo could be used for an ad, or what would happen if someone republished a photo from another photographer (be patient, i'm building it up).
The final thing came in the form of a column in this week's Advertising Age by Teressa Iezzi about the benefits of loose intellectual property. Her thesis is that copyrights that work for the creator(s) and bolster creativity in others benefits the economy.
Both Scott and Teressa write about the originality found in the advertising world. The creative work put out is 100% new and 100% improved. Original ideas are placed high atop pedestals for all to see. Kudos are given to those who came up with those brilliant ideas. But, these ideas often come from those innovators standing on the backs of those who came before. We appreciate the new because it captures us with the memories of the original, "the movie based on a musical based on a movie." Or more indirectly, from the literature and great works that were written long ago. Just like all great science fiction which strings together concepts from mythology, science, and folklore, great ads bring a new twist to a classic idea.
The question asked today takes someone's contribution and uses it to "sell." While not the original artistic goal, it serves the greater masses as a beacon of a brand. And in an ideal world, it benefits the artist, raising their profile and awareness. But, that's an ideal world.
I have struggled with a number of people because this sharing of ideas and work is often looked at with a certain level of disdain. I have to assume that many of the users on Flickr show their work because they want constructive criticism and help. This helps them hone their craft. The same idea should be placed behind those in advertising (and some level those who play in this new world wide web 2.0). Share and share alike. In fact this is one of the licensing options offered by the Creative Commons Organization, a pioneer in looser intellectual rights and creative control.
Knowledge has been transferred since the dawn of man through the sharing of stories. This idea of sharing has what has led to the greatest triumphs of our species. The Creative Commons license allows a creator to protect their work from exploitation but allowing others to use and learn from.
My real point of all this, is that if our creative, no matter how original, is loosely based on creative that came before it, why aren't we allowed to learn from and improve the ideas of some? I say this with some trepidation, because I don't believe that everything can and should be used for marketing. However, everything should be used as a learning experience. I should note, all this should be done legally.
That's my two cents, for another person's, keep reading Artificial Simplicity and for those who share their work online, visit the Creative Commons website and learn more about how to best share your work and about their mission and accomplishments.